EIP-1380: Reduced gas cost for call to self

Author	Alex Beregszaszi, Jacques Wagener
Discussions-To	https://ethereum-magicians.org/t/eip-1380-reduced-gas-cost-for-call-to-self/1242
Status	Stagnant
Type	Standards Track
Category	Core
Created	2018-08-31
Requires	150

Abstract

Reduce the gas cost for call instructions, when the goal is to run a new instance of the currently loaded contract.

Motivation

The current gas cost of 700 for all call types (CALL, DELEGATECALL, CALLCODE and STATICCALL) does not take into account that a call to a contract itself does not need to perform additional I/O operations, because the current contract code has already been loaded into memory.

Reducing the call-to-self gas cost would greatly benefit smart contract languages, such as Solidity and Vyper, who would then be able to utilise CALL instead of JUMP opcodes for internal function calls. While languages can already utilise CALL for internal function calls, they are discouraged to do so due to the gas costs associated with it.

Using JUMP comes at a considerable cost in complexity to the implementation of a smart contract language and/or compiler. The context (including stack and memory) must be swapped in and out of the calling functions context. A desired feature is having pure functions, which do not modify the state of memory, and realising them through JUMP requires a bigger effort from the compiler as opposed to being able to use CALLs.

Using call-to-self provides the guarantee that when making an internal call the function can rely on a clear reset state of memory or context, benefiting both contract writers and contract consumers against potentially undetetected edge cases were memory could poison the context of the internal function.

Because of the JUMP usage for internal functions a smart contract languages are also at risk of reaching the stack depth limit considerbly faster, if nested function calls with many in and/or outputs are required.

Reducing the gas cost, and thereby incentivising of using call-to-self instead of JUMPs for the internal function implementation will also benefit static analyzers and tracers.

Specification

If block.number >= FORK_BLKNUM, then decrease the cost of CALL, DELEGATECALL, CALLCODE and STATICCALL from 700 to 40, if and only if, the destination address of the call equals to the address of the caller.

Rationale

EIP150 has increased the cost of these instructions from 40 to 700 to more fairly charge for loading new contracts from disk, e.g. to reflect the I/O charge more closely. By assuming that 660 is the cost of loading a contract from disk, one can assume that the original 40 gas is a fair cost of creating a new VM instance of an already loaded contract code.

Backwards Compatibility

This should pose no risk to backwards compatibility. Currently existing contracts should not notice the difference, just see cheaper execution. With EIP150 contract (and language) developers had a lesson that relying on strict gas costs is not feasible as costs may change. The impact of this EIP is even less that of EIP150 because the costs are changing downwards and not upwards.

Test Cases

TBA

Implementation

TBA

Copyright

Copyright and related rights waived via CC0.

Citation

Please cite this document as:

Alex Beregszaszi, Jacques Wagener, "EIP-1380: Reduced gas cost for call to self," Ethereum Improvement Proposals, no. 1380, August 2018. [Online serial]. Available: https://eips.ethereum.org/EIPS/eip-1380.